My Go-To Cookie Icing for Actual Humans
Let me be real, I used to buy those squeeze tubes of cookie icing (you know the ones?) until my kids declared it too runny and, oh, the colors bled everywhere. Anyway, one snowy weekend I figured, fine, let’s whip up some icing like the cool folks on TV. A bit of flour in my hair, a sticky counter, and a slightly suspicious dog later—I found this is the glossy sugar cookie icing recipe I’ll probably never stop using. It’s almost suspiciously simple once you get the hang of it. But don’t tell my competitive aunt; she still thinks I took a course.
Why You’ll Love This Sticky, Shiny Magic
I haul out this recipe anytime someone claims decorating is hard—because it really is easy. My niece calls it ‘paint for cookies’ and, honestly, she eats a third of it before I even grab the food coloring. It’s glossy so the cookies look proper—like something you’d see in a bakery window, but it still tastes like real vanilla, not plastic. Oh, and it actually sets, so you can stack them (or, well, try… depends how thick you like it). I used to wrestle with royal icing but, actually, this is so much more forgiving. Plus, if you mess up your design, just eat the evidence. I do.
What You’ll Need—Plus My Little Shortcuts
- 2 cups powdered sugar (I really just plop it in, but if you have lumps, give it a sift—unless you’re feeling wild)
- 2 tablespoons milk (for a slightly thicker icing, use less; I’ve accidentally splashed in almond milk and it works, too!)
- 1 tablespoon light corn syrup (my grandmother swore by Karo, but I’ve used store brand in a pinch and nobody noticed)
- 1/2 teaspoon pure vanilla extract (or almond extract if you want a twist; sometimes I do half and half just for fun)
- Pinch of salt (optional—on days I remember)
- Food coloring (Whatever you have is fine—gels don’t run as much, but liquid works if that’s what you’ve got)
Let’s Get Mixing—With Some Wiggle Room
- In a medium bowl, toss in your powdered sugar. Don’t worry too much if it’s not exact—I sometimes toss in just a shade more for a super-thick batch.
- Add the milk, corn syrup, and vanilla. Give it a gentle mix; it’ll look weird and gloopy at first. This is totally normal and honestly, this is where I usually sneak a taste. If it’s too thick, just drizzle in ½ teaspoon more milk at a time. If too thin, add a sprinkle more sugar.
- Pop in a pinch of salt (I skip it when I forget, which is more often than not!), then stir till it’s smooth and glossy. You want it to run off the spoon but hold a line for a second or two—that’s the sweet spot.
- Split the icing into bowls and swirl in food coloring. I use toothpicks for gel, but use whatever makes you happy. Don’t go wild right away; a little color goes a long way.
- Spoon or pipe onto cooled cookies. If spread with a knife, it has a rustic charm (or so I tell myself). Let ’em dry for at least 6 hours. (I know, that’s ages. But trust me—the shine is worth it.)
The Messy Notes I’ve Collected (So Far)
- Actually, if you use almond extract, it kind of steals the show—sometimes my family likes it more than vanilla.
- If the icing starts to set while you’re working, just give it a stir and it’s back to normal.
- I tried skipping the corn syrup once. Regretted it—the icing just wasn’t shiny. Learn from my mistake!
I’ve Tried These Tweaks—Most Worked, One Did Not
- For lemon flavor, swap in lemon juice instead of some of the milk. Not too much, though—one time I did, and it turned out runny as soup. Tasted good but went everywhere.
- A dash of cinnamon in the icing for snickerdoodle vibes. Kids call it the ‘cozy batch.’
- I once tried honey (instead of corn syrup) during a midnight baking panic. It sort of worked, but the shine just wasn’t there. Wouldn’t bother again, to be honest.
Equipment—And What To Do If You Don’t Have It
- Mixing bowl (if you’re desperate, a big mug totally works)
- Spoon or silicone spatula
- Sifter for sugar (sometimes I just bash the bag and hope for the best)
- Piping bags, sandwich bags, or even the corner of a plastic produce bag snipped off if you can’t find yours (I’ve been there)
- Toothpicks for swirling colors (fingers work… just don’t blame me!)
How Long Does It Keep?
Once dry, the icing holds up for about a week—if you’re the sort of person with self control. I very rarely am, so that’s purely theoretical. If you’ve got leftover icing, shove it in an airtight container; it keeps in the fridge for 2-3 days. Just stir before using (I mean it).
How We Actually Serve These
You can show off these cookies at holidays—Christmas, sure, but they’re also fab for birthdays. Sometimes we do a ‘decorate your own cookie’ bar at parties. My mum always dunks hers in tea—even the frosted ones. Try it and see if you’re into it.
Pro Tips (a.k.a Lessons I Learned the Hard Way)
- Don’t try to rush the drying step. I once bit into a cookie too soon, and icing went everywhere, including on my cat (she was not amused).
- Color gets darker as it sits. Go easy at first. Or you’ll end up with colors you probably didn’t want (ask me about my muddy purple disaster someday).
- If you overdo the milk, the icing will drip off the cookie faster than you can say “oops.” Add more sugar and all is forgiven.
FAQ—Questions I’ve Actually Heard (or Wondered Myself)
- Does this icing taste better than royal icing? Personally, yes. It’s sweeter, less chalky, and kids seem to love it. My friend Susan still swears by royal, but I’m not convinced.
- Can I freeze decorated cookies? Sure thing! They stay pretty, but let them dry completely first. Sometimes the shine dulls a bit, but no one’s complained yet.
- What if I don’t have corn syrup? You can skip it, but don’t expect that shiny, bakery finish. On second thought, a drizzle of maple syrup sort of works for flavor, but it does get sticky.
- Is this safe for young kids to help with? Absolutely! Just cover your table—because, well, they get a bit wild.
- Why does my icing look dull? Usually means too little corn syrup or it hasn’t dried long enough. Or maybe it’s just a gloomy day? Ambient mood totally affects baking, right?
Oh, one more thing—I usually make an extra batch because someone (me, usually) always forgets to save a couple plain for later. But hey, life’s too short not to eat the pretty cookies while they’re fresh. Hope you have fun making these as much as I do (and if there’s a mess, well, welcome to the club!).
Ingredients
- 2 cups powdered sugar (sifted if you’re feeling fancy, or just dump it in)
- 2 tablespoons milk (plus more for thinning)
- 1 tablespoon light corn syrup
- 1/2 teaspoon pure vanilla extract (or almond extract, or both)
- Pinch of salt (optional)
- Food coloring (gels, liquids, whatever you’ve got really)
Instructions
-
1In a medium bowl, toss in your powdered sugar. Don’t worry too much if it’s not exact—I sometimes toss in just a shade more for a super-thick batch.
-
2Add the milk, corn syrup, and vanilla. Give it a gentle mix; it’ll look weird and gloopy at first. This is totally normal and honestly, this is where I usually sneak a taste. If it’s too thick, just drizzle in ½ teaspoon more milk at a time. If too thin, add a sprinkle more sugar.
-
3Pop in a pinch of salt (I skip it when I forget, which is more often than not!), then stir till it’s smooth and glossy. You want it to run off the spoon but hold a line for a second or two—that’s the sweet spot.
-
4Split the icing into bowls and swirl in food coloring. I use toothpicks for gel, but use whatever makes you happy. Don’t go wild right away; a little color goes a long way.
-
5Spoon or pipe onto cooled cookies. If spread with a knife, it has a rustic charm (or so I tell myself). Let ’em dry for at least 6 hours. (I know, that’s ages. But trust me—the shine is worth it.)
Approximate Information for One Serving
Nutrition Disclaimers
Number of total servings shown is approximate. Actual number of servings will depend on your preferred portion sizes.
Nutritional values shown are general guidelines and reflect information for 1 serving using the ingredients listed, not including any optional ingredients. Actual macros may vary slightly depending on specific brands and types of ingredients used.
To determine the weight of one serving, prepare the recipe as instructed. Weigh the finished recipe, then divide the weight of the finished recipe (not including the weight of the container the food is in) by the desired number of servings. Result will be the weight of one serving.
Did you make this recipe?
Please consider Pinning it!
