Let’s Chat: Cookie Dough in a Cup? Oh Yes (Trust Me)
Alright, so true confession time: I never believed in “healthy” desserts (the kind that are “really just as good!” except, well, they’re not) until I whipped up these high protein yogurt cookie dough cups. The first batch was, um, not my greatest hit – my brother said they tasted “sorta like if the gym made a dessert” (which, rude). But I fiddled with the combo (less chalky protein powder, more vanilla, and hey, let’s be honest, decent chocolate chips help a LOT) and now we’re obsessed. One time I took these to a picnic and my friend Sarah thought they were little cheesecakes, so I just let her believe it.
Why You’ll Probably Make These on Repeat
I throw these together after a workout when I need something sweet but, you know, not the full-on cake sugar bomb. My family goes nuts for ’em because, honestly, they’re grab-and-go (unless someone eats them all before dinner… Ben, I’m looking at you). Plus, I always wanted an excuse to eat cookie dough and this is actually encouraged. Sometimes the hardest bit is waiting for them to chill, but I’ve learned—don’t yank ’em out too soon, or they’re, well, goo. Not in a good way. (Learned that the sticky-fingered way, haha.)
Here’s What You Need (and a Few Swaps I’ve Tried)
- 1 cup thick Greek yogurt (I usually use whole milk, but low-fat works—I had to once when I mistook the tub in a rush. Still delish, but a bit less creamy)
- 1/2 cup vanilla protein powder (I bounce between whey or plant-based—honestly, any decent-tasting powder will do. Avoid the really chalky bargain bin stuff…)
- 1/2 cup almond flour (regular flour if you aren’t fussed about grain-free. My Aunt Sheila swears by coconut flour but I found it a tad dry)
- 2 tbsp maple syrup (or honey, or even agave; sometimes I just use what’s on hand—one horrible time, I tried date syrup, nope, not for me!)
- 1/2 tsp vanilla extract (I eyeball this, splash more if I’m feeling reckless)
- Pinch salt (coarse is fine, sea salt is a treat—go wild)
- 1/3 cup mini chocolate chips (more or less, no one is counting. Swap for chopped nuts, dried fruit, or whatever feels right. You do you)
Let’s Make It: How I Fumble My Way Through
- First, grab a medium bowl. If you’re like me, that means washing a bowl from last night’s popcorn. Plop in your yogurt and protein powder. Stir slowly unless you enjoy the protein powder cloud of doom.
- Add almond flour, maple syrup, vanilla, and salt. Don’t panic if it looks a bit, how do I say, sticky and odd—give it a good mix. Sometimes I switch to a spatula when the spoon gets stuck. Actually, don’t use a flimsy spoon; trust me.
- This is usually where I sneak a taste. For quality control. Or maybe just because. Adjust sweetness if you fancy (that’s why I keep the syrup nearby).
- Fold in the chocolate chips real gentle. Or dump ’em in and stir if you’re impatient, it’ll work either way (I’ve tested both; somehow, both delicious).
- Spoon the dough into silicone cupcake liners, or trust your fate to a muffin tray with paper liners. Honestly, finger licking is inevitable, so give up on “clean hands” here.
- Chill in the fridge for at least 90 minutes (important! They set up and actually hold their shape then. I once tried the freezer—set my timer for 20 minutes, got distracted, came back to…well, cookie dough ice rocks, so don’t do that.)
Notes & Mishaps (Seriously, Don’t Skip These)
- If you find the dough too runny, add a sprinkle more almond flour. Once, I added too much and got “cookie bread”—still tasty, just not a cup.
- Overmixing makes it weirdly gummy. That’s my bad habit—learn from my mistakes.
- And if they taste a bit too “yogurty” straight out of the fridge, let them sit 5 mins. Flavors mellow, I swear.
Variations: The Good, the Bad, and the Weird
- Add cinnamon or espresso powder (my “pick-me-up” version, just don’t accidentally go heavy on the coffee. Made it once, couldn’t sleep—oops.)
- Peanut butter swirl is magic—just stir in a dollop before chilling. Almond butter works too.
- Ignore TikTok and don’t try mixing in matcha. Did that. Regret. Bitter, green, nope.
Don’t Worry About Fancy Gear (Or, How I Survived Without It)
If you’ve got a mixing bowl and a fork, you’re golden. Silicone liners are nice for popping the cups out, but honestly? An ice cube tray works in a pinch or you just grease a muffin tray and call it rustic. No stand mixer needed—hand power is fine, think of it as a tiny arm workout.
Storing These (If You Actually Have Leftovers)
Once set, pop ’em in an airtight container in the fridge—they keep for, I dunno, four days? But honestly, in my house, they vanish by the next morning. I tried freezing a few once for “portion control.” Hah. Queue me eating frozen cookie dough like some kind of yeti.
How I Love to Serve ‘Em (and You Might Too)
Honestly, sometimes I sprinkle a little flaky salt on top, especially if they need some zing. My niece likes them with fresh strawberries on the side (go figure?). And if it’s just for me, I crumble one over a bowl of oatmeal for a not-at-all-subtle breakfast treat. No regrets.
Pro Tips: Learn From My Cookie Dough Drama
- Don’t rush the chill step. I once tried speeding it with the freezer and got sad, icy cups—texture totally off.
- Taste and adjust before you spoon into cups. If it’s a little bland, prob needs more syrup or a pinch more salt (yes, salt. Trust me).
- Keep the cups small. Giant ones get, well, soupy. Lesson learned on a crazy-hot July day.
FAQ (From Real People Like My Mum and Friends)
- Q: Can I use regular yogurt, not Greek?
A: Kind of. It’ll be looser, but just use more flour. Or strain it with a coffee filter for an hour—learned that trick here! - Q: Does the protein powder flavor matter?
A: Yep. Some taste, um, like cardboard. I like Optimum Nutrition, but actually, anything you can eat straight is fine. You could check out this Bob’s Red Mill guide for ideas. - Q: Are these supposed to be super sweet?
A: Not really! They’re more chewy and creamy. If you want a full-on cookie vibe, add more syrup or chocolate, why not? - Q: What if I want to make them vegan?
A: Easy—use plant-based yogurt and vegan protein, swap honey for maple. No fuss. - Q: Can kids help?
A: Oh sure! Just expect more licking than stirring. (And, possibly, fewer cups actually make it to the fridge…)
Anyway, now you’ve got all my high protein yogurt cookie dough cup secrets. If you mess up, just call it “deconstructed dessert”—fancy, right? Enjoy cooking, and remember, dessert is supposed to be fun, not perfect.
Ingredients
- 1 cup Greek yogurt, plain or vanilla
- 1 cup almond flour
- 1/3 cup vanilla protein powder
- 3 tbsp maple syrup or honey
- 2 tbsp mini chocolate chips
- 2 tbsp unsweetened almond butter
- 1 tsp vanilla extract
- Pinch of salt
Instructions
-
1Line a muffin tin with 6 silicone or paper liners.
-
2In a large bowl, mix together almond flour, protein powder, salt, and 1 tablespoon of chocolate chips.
-
3Add Greek yogurt, maple syrup, almond butter, and vanilla extract. Stir until a thick cookie dough consistency forms.
-
4Spoon equal amounts of the mixture into the prepared muffin cups and smooth the tops.
-
5Sprinkle the remaining chocolate chips on top. Freeze or refrigerate the cups for at least 1 hour to set.
-
6Remove from liners and enjoy cold. Store leftovers covered in the refrigerator.
Approximate Information for One Serving
Nutrition Disclaimers
Number of total servings shown is approximate. Actual number of servings will depend on your preferred portion sizes.
Nutritional values shown are general guidelines and reflect information for 1 serving using the ingredients listed, not including any optional ingredients. Actual macros may vary slightly depending on specific brands and types of ingredients used.
To determine the weight of one serving, prepare the recipe as instructed. Weigh the finished recipe, then divide the weight of the finished recipe (not including the weight of the container the food is in) by the desired number of servings. Result will be the weight of one serving.
Did you make this recipe?
Please consider Pinning it!!
